PEER
RESPONSE SHEET FOR
IDEAS AND CONTENT
Below is a version of the peer
response sheet I have my students use when reading another
student's paper for ideas and content. I have changed the format
to fit the confines of this web page. I usually have a line in
front of each statement and one in the middle so that students
can mark a particular item as being a strength, in the middle, or
a weakness.
DIRECTIONS: Circle what you believe to be the correct
response to the paper.
Overall paper is interesting OR Overall
paper is somewhat interesting OR Overall paper
is boring
Writer stays on topic OR Writer occasionally goes off topic
OR Writer
goes off topic often or has no clear topic
Purpose of paper is clear OR Purpose
of the paper is somewhat clear OR Reader is
unsure of the purpose
Paper contains supporting details OR Paper
contains some supporting details OR Topic is
general and not supported by details
Paper seems to be written from experience OR Some
of the paper is written from experience, some of it is not
believable OR Paper
is not believable
